Yes, this product can smudge a tad, but this is because it is made with beeswax instead of heavy synthetics. Having oily eye lids can make it more difficult to wear any mascara at all, but it really depends on the shape of your eyes; do your lashes touch your lids or brow bone?
Quick beauty fix: use some Dr. Feel good or Stay Don't Stray on your lids, then apply a neutral powder eyeshadow to keep your lids matte. Follow with a highlight in the brow bone, such as high brow. This will keep your mascara from smudging.
velvet eyeshadow - rich beach
5 years, 3 months ago