my old liner wasn't cutting it. (maybe they changed their formula?) I tried Magic Ink and was instantly hooked! so so black. doesn't leave a dull color. goes on smooth. I've been using liquid eyeliner since I was 14... (15+ years) this is by far the best I've ever had. thanks benefit.
I have a terrible time with eyeliners smearing. I was using Shea Laque over my eyeliner never had a smearing problem. Shea Laque is now no longer available and I am i a bind trying to keep my eyelinr from smudging.